Entitled 28-year-old brother gets miffed because his older sister only permits him to crash on her couch, claiming he deserves the privacy of her home office: 'There is no third room'

Advertisement
  • Young man in the living room with a suitcase
  • AITA for refusing to let brother move into my home office I (35F) work from home as a technical writer. My job requires a lot of focused time, weekly online meetings, and constant access to my equipment. Because of this, I
  • converted our spare bedroom into a dedicated home office desk, monitors, filing cabinets, the works. It's not fancy, but it's functional and absolutely necessary for my income.
  • My younger brother "Kyle" (28M) recently went through a breakup and moved out of the apartment he shared with his ex. He stayed with a friend temporarily, but the
  • friend told him he needed the room back for a relative. Kyle then came to me, asking if he could stay "just a month or two" while he gets back on his feet.
  • I was willing to help, but we live in a small two-bedroom townhouse: one bedroom is mine and my wife's, the other is my office. There is no third room. I told Kyle he could stay on the pull-out sofa
  • in the living room. It's comfortable enough, and we have a TV, bathroom access, kitchen, everything he needs for a short-term arrangement.
  • He immediately dismissed the idea, saying he needed "privacy" and "a real bedroom" to "get his life back together." He insisted that I could work "just as easily" from the dining table or couch.
  • When I said that wasn't possible because my job requires quiet, interviews, meetings, and confidential materials, he told me I was being dramatic.
  • Woman upset with a man
  • Kyle then argued that family should come before work, and accused me of choosing "a room full of screens" over helping him. I reminded him that my income depended on that room, and without my income, I couldn't help anyone.
  • He got frustrated and said it was "just a room" and that he'd only need it temporarily. I told him again that he could stay on the sofa but the office wasn't an option. He refused and said staying in the living room made him feel "like a guest," which, frankly, he would be.
  • so, AITA FOR REFUSING TO LET MY BROTHER MOVE INTO MY HOME OFFICE?
  • Ok_Conversation9... . NTA at all. People seeking a free place to crash don't get to dictate what room they get, etc. If he needs privacy to get his life together, then he can get a nice, private motel room.
  • Trailsya He said "no." to your offer. This is not a business deal, where both people want something (goods/services one way, money the other). Only he wants something, so you don't need to negotiate.
  • So "no." is a no. Not start of negotiations. Don't let him in. With that attitude, chances are he won't leave within 2 months.
  • There is probably a reason Kyle's friend has "a relative" moving in suddenly and that reason is likely that your brother is annoying to live with.
  • Stop discussing this with him. Stop offering. Stop even talking to him for a while. He should be grateful instead of entitled.
  • Designer_Zone6327 Hahaha, I can quickly see why your brother went through a breakup! What a piece of work.
  • No means no. And 'no' is a whole sentence. He can either gracefully accept the offer or find something better. But instead, he starts to demand and gaslight and guilttrip.
  • You are berter off with him some place far away! NTA. Don't even question yourself that!

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article